Aparna’s Weekend Musings on Life – Series 13 – A Woman’s Musings!
Every year we celebrate women’s day celebrating women empowerment, be inspired by those women who have achieved great things and we get special discounts in retails, restaurants and many more. But why does a woman have to fight for her own voice in many families still? It stems from our family system, some age old myths and practices.
“Most
women are searching for freedom within families not freedom from families. They
want to find the ‘I’ within the ‘We’ as they navigate the world inside and
outside their home. – Deepa Narayanan”
I use the context of patriarchy to describe the power
relationship between men & women, as well as to find out the root cause of
gender inequality even in mindset.
Patriarchy is a
socially-constructed system where a male has primary power.
In the patriarchal setup in Indian family system, women are assigned the
more "menial" tasks, which are constantly
underrated and undervalued by men. A woman’s whole identity revolves around
caring for children, cooking, washing, cleaning and caring for the family. This was the mindset many decades back and is
still prevalent in lot of families.
A young child is highly likely to grow up with an over involved mother
whose existence is defined by the child; a father who is out making a living,
taking decisions, getting involved in more important matters of the household
like finances - activities where a woman does not belong. The fathers are
typically not very involved in the child's upbringing leaving the mothers to
handle. This is what the child sees and is familiar with. Also young girl
children are often suppressed and not allowed to talk in front of adults or
freely express their opinions in this family system and this forms a
stereotyped thinking in the young male child on how to treat women.
At the very least, the boy from this family structure grows up to be a
man with some serious dissonance when he sees women living life for reasons
other than having a baby, raising a child or cooking and cleaning. Though he
accepts a girl studying in school / college along with him, working in his
office. The problem arises when he gets an a woman with progressive thoughts as
his life partner. He cant accept her as his equal, how can she take decisions,
get into debates and express opinions in front of him or his family?
But there is more. This person can go through a difficult and unsettling
process of individuation or lack of it psychologically. Individuation is an
important ongoing psychological process that every person goes through as it enables
the separation of an individual from his/her primary caregiver and defines who
they are as a person. The process begins when we are toddlers and continues
through life at various stages.
In the case of most of male population in India, the individuation from
their mothers doesn’t happen in a healthy manner nor do they go through the
healthy stages of individuation in their later life. To a large extent, Indian
society praises mothers whose whole purpose of life is serve to her grown up
sons even in her old age. Their identity revolves around this, creating an
excessive interdependence between mother and son.
Many women sacrifice their personal pleasure and ambitions, sets
standard of morality, relieves stress and strain of her family, maintains peace
and order in the household.
There are some positive shifts. Challenging
patriarchy is something that has been happening for generations, and it will
probably take many more generations before it can be eliminated.
However, there are many ways we can push back
against the system of patriarchy.
I believe a lot of patriarchy can only be broken by mothers. By them
cultivating an identity for themselves and living lives that don't just revolve
around their strict gender role. They don't necessarily have to destroy the
family structure that we are used to, but they can certainly break the
excessive interdependence between mother and child.
Some questions to help the family system to think
progressively:
· Do we really think men and women are equal? If yes, how can we start implementing it as a family? If no, why not start now!
Why don’t we teach children of both genders to treat each other with respect?
· Why should only girl
children be scolded for talking back to elders or be suppressed to express
their opinion right from young age? If talking back to elders is not a good
habit, shouldn’t boy children be taught that too? Shouldn’t children of both
genders be taught to express their opinion? Isnt that progressive for a family?
·
Why shouldn’t a woman
live her dreams without being the mythological superwoman who handles her
household responsibilities too? Doesn’t this society excuse men who are
climbing the corporate ladder or the entrepreneurial business ladder? Why not
ask them to be superman and handle household responsibilities too?
·
Can we start equal sharing of household workload in
every family right from planning meals to cleaning the house?
·
Can we stop pushing off the entire responsibility
of managing the house to mothers? Yes they do take the load willingly for their
family but can we start sharing their workload a little? Homemakers work
tirelessly yet their efforts are never recognized, appreciated & always
undermined, can we change that as a family?
· Can we consider a women to be equal in the
corporate world and start paying her equal to men?
· Can we stop undervaluing a woman’s work experience
because she took a maternity break?
· Can we stop judging a woman for her looks, gossips
unnecessarily about her or judge her? Can we stop doing to other women even to
those whom you have never met or comment on social media? Who are we to comment
on how an actress or vj looks or talks? Isnt that body shaming too?
Freedom for a woman is like oxygen for her soul! A
Girl or Woman Can Be Two Things: Who & What She Wants! No one can repress a
woman unless she holds back herself. Her freedom or servitude is in
her mind!
Regards,
Aparna Subramanian
#women'sdaythoughts# #a woman;s musings#
You raised some very valid questions that we need to reflect on. Just blindly celebrating Women's day and not really understanding the needs of women in the family is laughable. I fully agree with you on the mindset of the the Indian society, still very much patriarchal in every sense. Sadly, a woman's education and her intellectual ability mean nothing unless she can cook, clean and take care of the family and household work. But having moved to a society where intelligence and ability are appreciated before anything else, well not always but at least to a better degree, I consider myself lucky. It is very disheartening to hear that a woman 2 decades from my time in India is still thinking the same thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI am going to try and best answer your questions based on my own experience.
1. Do we really think men and women are equal? If yes, how can we start implementing it as a family? If no, why not start now!
Yes & No. It depends. Would we say men and women are equal when it comes to doing lot of heavy physical work? Like lifting heavy things or driving 8 hours straight? So there must be healthy discussion around who CAN do vs who SHOULD do.
2.Why don’t we teach children of both genders to treat each other with respect?
Every human being deserves to be treated with respect. There is no men or women in that.
3.Why should only girl children be scolded for talking back to elders or be suppressed to express their opinion right from young age? If talking back to elders is not a good habit, shouldn’t boy children be taught that too? Shouldn’t children of both genders be taught to express their opinion? Isnt that progressive for a family?
Yes, behavioral expectations should be the same for both genders
4.Why shouldn’t a woman live her dreams without being the mythological superwoman who handles her household responsibilities too? Doesn’t this society excuse men who are climbing the corporate ladder or the entrepreneurial business ladder? Why not ask them to be superman and handle household responsibilities too?
This again depends on situation. What if the man is also equally climbing the corporate ladder? If they have kids then who would watch them? There is no right or wrong as long they both come up with a strategy that works for their family.
5.Can we start equal sharing of household workload in every family right from planning meals to cleaning the house? They should and must. It is already happening in a lotof families, young & old that I know.
Absolutely, it should be shared and there is no men or women's work.
6.Can we stop pushing off the entire responsibility of managing the house to mothers? Yes they do take the load willingly for their family but can we start sharing their workload a little? Homemakers work tirelessly yet their efforts are never recognized, appreciated & always undermined, can we change that as a family?
Yes, this should be cultivated in children at young age. There is no boy or girl, equally both.
7.Can we consider a women to be equal in the corporate world and start paying her equal to men?
Is this not happening already?
8· Can we stop undervaluing a woman’s work experience because she took a maternity break? in US definitely it is not.
India will get there some day hopefully soon.
9· Can we stop judging a woman for her looks, gossips unnecessarily about her or judge her? Can we stop doing to other women even to those whom you have never met or comment on social media? Who are we to comment on how an actress or vj looks or talks? Isnt that body shaming too?
Yes, this can come only with good upbringing where the mother and father do not gossip. People need to find better hobbies and ways to make themselves feel good without indulging in gossip or other demeaning activities.